Showing posts with label writings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label writings. Show all posts

Monday, September 26, 2011

$250 for a photo with a naked man?

a stark naked man has attracted attention from hundreds of people at the Art Stage Singapore exhibition, held at Marina Bay Sands. The man is seated in a booth in front of Mexican artist Frida Kahlo's "The Two Fridas", devoid of any article of clothing. Visitors to the exhibition can choose to join him in the room, hold his hand (mimicing the painting behind), and get a photograph taken for a price of $250.

the man, T. Venkanna, is an artist from Hyderabad, India and is posing naked as part of his art installation about "removing the trappings of identity".

I feel that art comes in many forms, be it a renaissance romanticist painting by theodore gericault, or a ready-made my marcel duchamp. and although i concede that what T. Venkanna is doing is indeed art (performance art), i decline to agree that it was well done.

through the process of coursework, my (vague-ish) principles of art have become relatively more concrete. but i realised that a key aspect of art that i feel is important and necessary is that throughout the process of doing the art, there must be some visible effort or growth on the part of the artist - like the evident patience and skill needed to paint "A Sunday on the island of La Grande Jatte", or the hours' effort needed to throw a simple vase. i personally feel that, more than the symbolism of the work, the process and sense of achievement after a period of hard work is what makes art. However in the case of T. Venkanna, I feel that he has put in little or no effort into this work as all he needs to do is sit there and take pictures. There is no necessary artistic skills involved, or creative idea behind it. Moreover, i find this installation rather "cheat" (for lack of a better word), as not only does he need to put in little effort on his part, the painting that he is basing his entire installation on isn't even painted by him. thus in my opinion, i find this installation a very poorly executed example of performance art.

also, "The Two Fridas" was painted by Frida Kahlo at a time of her divorce with her ex-husband, Diego Rivera. The painting thus serves to depict Kahlo's emotions, inner turmoil and the great pain she was suffering at the time. There is no direct (or indirect) link between the painting and T. Venkenna's concept of "removing the trappings of identity". It seems as though the only similarities between what he is doing and the painting is the pose of the two fridas and the pose of T. Venkenna and the visitor. In anycase, even if T. Venkenna did intend to portray "removing the trappings of identity" as perhaps, removing the trappings of sorrow and pain as in "The Two Fridas", I still feel that he should not have mimicked another artist's work, as this causes him to lose his originality as an artist, which contradicts his prominent and outstanding actions.

another reason that i do not like this work is the way the message was portrayed. removing clothes and accessories does not necessarily equate to "removing the trappings of identity", or is a vague and superficial representation of it. I also think that T. Venkenna has failed to properly convey his message to his viewers, as most people view his nudity not as an image conveying the message of "removing the trappings of identity", but more as something that attracts attention because of the outrageous nature of the installation. Also, the fact that 70% of the visitors who have taken a photo with him are women, and that most of them did not dare to look him in the eye, were shy and did not speak to him may suggest that they are simply there because of a certain morbid curiousity, instead of a desire to appreciate art. Also, the extra measures taken to screen the exhibit from the public area to avoid visitors from stumbling upon it by accident is, albeit a thoughtful precaution, but it also suggests that the main aspect of the installation that people pay attention to is the nudity of the man, instead of the message he is trying to convey. As such, I think that T. Venkenna has mostly failed to convey his message through his actions.

footnote: while my comments on this installation have been sardonic and cynical, i do applaud the artist's courage to display himself to the public, and that all of these comments are my own personal views which may differ from others. ^^

Wednesday, September 21, 2011

final. (FINALLY.)

finally! after one year, this is my final :D 4 trees, 4 candles, 4 choices. which is yours?
as far as all my trees go this has to be my favourite. its the spring tree, with new leaves just sprouting out, symbolising hope of new life, and hope for change, as the tree will not stop here but continue to grow leaves till it has a full crown. spring is a very hopeful season :) for farmers, it means the snow will melt and their plants will grow again, for people, it (usually) means a new year and new beginnings, for animals it means the coming of warmer weather. the birdhouse is the candle holder because spring is the time where birds return, after migrating before winter, symbolising the return of hope and life.

my comments: this tree was inspired by my spaghetti tree, except i blended the spaghetti together partially so that it looks a lot more realistic. the birdhouse was /supposed/ to be on the tree, but it fell off so i'm going to stick it back after everything is fired ^^ the red+grey oxide really came through when i was glazing the birdhouse. the brown that was created made the birdhouse look very woody and nice :D
summer. the hottest period of the year, but the favourite season of trees. in the summer, they are at their prime, with huge crowns of bright green leaves, soaking up the sun. the hot sun is the source of hope for the trees, as it promises food, light, warmth and life. also, for people seeking shade from the sweltering heat, the great crowns of the tree provide the perfect place to sit under and perhaps read a book, or swing from a branch.

my comments: don't look at it now, but the tree and all the rocks are actually not attached to each other. they (heh) sort of broke apart due to poor joining but its okay! it can be salvaged :D the thing i regret most about this sculpture is still not being able to shape the crown more realistically. (plus, i probably shouldn't have added so much oxide to it either ><)
autumn - the season of harvest. this is the season that farmers have been looking forward to all year, as it is finally the time they can reap the fruits of their harvest. not only do farmers hope for this season, trees do too. their fruits are finally grown and the seeds in them can be dispersed to grow into more trees. autumn is the season of hope of more food, harvest, and new life. so i thought it would be apt to let the object of all this hope - the fruit - be the main part of the sculpture, the place where the candle is placed. the apple symbolises fertility and new life. due to greek mythology, the apple is also associated with Aphrodite, and to throw an apple at someone was to symbolically declare one's love. not only so, the apple also plays a big part in the creation of life, as it was the forbidden fruit in the garden of eden.

my comments: the apple fell off again D:< but kay lah it was cause i hollowed the apple slantedly because the apple was going to lean on the tree so the "floor" that the candle is supposed to be on had to be parallel to the floor.. so as a result the c.g. went bazongkers and it couldn't stay on the tree >:
winter. the time of bitter cold and harsh snow. but even though times are bitter, hope is burning bright in everyone's hearts, providing them with the warmth and strength to survive the winter. a den is used as the place to hold the candle to emphasise on this point. animals like bears and foxes seek refuge from the cold in their warm dens, and hibernate throughout the winter, in hope of waking up to a warmer, greener place. by placing a candle in the den, i hoped to symbolise the hope that the animals and people hold in their hearts and minds, the hope that gives them the power and will to survive through winter.

my comments: haha i don't know why but this sculpture looked alot better when it wasn't painted >: but even though winter is supposed to be cold and harsh, its my favourite season (competing with autumn). there is just something so attractive about a scenery with the ground covered in sheets of white, and fluffy white flakes drifting down.. (kay fine i probably like winter because i'm been living in summer my whole life) but still ^^ I really like my den by the way. from behind it looks just like a big rock, which suits the natural feel of the sculpture ^^

dreams. what will we do with(out) them?

credits! this is valerie's coursework but i thought it was really cool and so i'm going to try and interpret it. (SORRY VAL IF I MISINTERPRETED SOME STUFF OR LEFT OUT SOME THINGS!)
the story starts when we're little. when we are small, and asked the question: "what are your dreams?", a thousand ideas burst into our heads. Although answers may vary with each ask of the question, we never fail to provide an answer. Practicalities or societal norms or economical problems don't plague our heads as we dream our dreams at that age. We are secure in our innocence, and peaceful in oblivion to the harsh realities of the world - as is clearly shown in the young girl's peaceful expression as she draws. This is the age where you don't think too much into things, and its okay to be different. The bright pink of her shirt shows her uniqueness and the brightness of her dreams, unclouded by fear or reality. The amount of colours in the colour pencils she securely holds show the vibrancy and diversity of her dreams. Her cup is upright, secure, and packed full of colour pencils - essentuating how secure she is at this age. The positioning of her in the smack center of the painting adds to the feeling of security in the painting. The blank paper shows her potential for dreaming. She is a blank slate, capable of being anything she wants to be. She is (for lack of a better phrase,) in her own world; a world full of bright colours, and innocent ideals, where black is black, white is white. The chair in front of the painting is carefully tailored to ensure the chair will not wobble, further emphasising her security in her world. It also has a drawer under the seat, which i feel is a nice touch because it adds to the air of innocence since little kids often have a secret compartment (like a drawer) where they stash their most precious things (or dreams). However, it is not painted; which could symbolise how incomplete her view of the world is, or the amount of life she has experienced thus far, or her state as a blank slate, her potential to dream and develop.

The cup is whole, and full.
the story continues as the girl grows up to become a teenager. we enter the stage of adolescence, a stage of maturity, a stage of growing up. this is the most unstable part of life, as we are exposed to the true face of the world with all its problems, norms and realities. as we go through this period of rapid growth and exposure, we face the struggle of finding ourselves, our insecurities, and continuing to hold on to our dreams. The girl is positioned at the side of the painting showing a rather unstable view of the painting. We see the vast difference between this picture and the previous picture, evident in the girl's expression and the colour of her shirt. In the first picture, her expression was one of peaceful security; now, she hosts a face of shock as she is faced with the world she is expected to accept and conform to. In the first picture, her shirt was a bright pink that contrasted starkly with the white background, showing her uniqueness and brightness of her world; now, the tones have cooled to blue with a white collar, as though showing how she is turning into the white background bit by bit, losing her some of her uniqueness and brightness. But the colour of her shirt is still a bright, vivid blue, showing the "bit by bit" part of growing up, instead of turning dull all of a sudden, thus giving the sense of transition into the paintings. In actual fact, the most eye-catching bit of this painting, is that everything is partial: The shirt is partially coloured (collar white), the cups are partially coloured cups, the chair in front in partially painted, and it has a partial leg, making the chair very unstable. All this serves to emphasise the girl being "neither here nor there", as she is in a stage of transition - neither a young naive girl, nor a mature adult woman. She struggles to keep hold of her dreams, and finds it very much harder than before due to the fact that she has left her sanctuary of innocence.

The cup stumbles, and falls.
this one is a bit harder to explain. so you've lived your share of life, seen lots of things, experienced lots of things - good, or bad. your dream cup is battered and cracked despite many attempts to repair it. The woman's expression is blank, her eyes staring, unfocused, into the distance as though reminiscing about her past, be it her successes, or her failures. Her shirt is now completely white, just a shade brighter than the background. The painting is rather devoid of colour, as the woman has now lost most of her innocence. Her dream cup seems to symbolise her state as of now - battered, but still able to hold some water. It seems to say that although she is not the blank slate she was years ago, she still has a chance to fulfill her dreams - if she takes the chance. Will she just abandon her cup because it leaks? Or still try to mend it and make it usable? This is further emphasized by the chair in front of the painting, which is narrow and with a low back rest. As you sit on it, you feel a sense of discomfort at the narrow seat, and if you lean back, you feel insecure immediately, not knowing if you will be supported by a back rest, or just tumble backwards to the ground. It symbolises that there is always a dream out there, even for this woman. All that is needed is a little faith, and a willingness to take the risk and try.

The cup is cracked. Not broken.

Monday, September 19, 2011

labyrinth-

"Labyrinth", (1987-8), Dede Eri Supria

I really like the amount of symbolism and meaning, as well as the significance of the message this painting conveys. The first thing that would strike people is the sheer size of the painting. At 200x250cm, this painting can dominate an entire wall, forcefully and deliberately attracting the attention of any who pass it. In addition to size, the artist has used bright colours to further enhance the eye-catching effect, as though to say "hey look here! the message i want to tell you can't wait any longer!"

Next to draw the eye would be the vast labyrinth of cardboard boxes, decorated with an array of well-known brands that we probably encounter in our everyday lives. The labyrinth stretches to the top of the painting, becoming increasingly packed and complicated as it goes up to create a sense of depth and perspective, making viewers wonder if there is even an end to this maze. The cardboard boxes seems almost sinister in this painting because of the way they are portrayed as the walls of this never-ending maze. They serve as the evidence of the rapid consumerism that has steadily increased throughout the passing years. On top of that, metal bars (not unlike those frequently seen in construction sites) weave through the cardboard boxes, strengthening their structure. The appearance of construction bars seems to draw a connection to the industrial revolution, as metal is mostly seen as an unnatural, man-made, industrial material. Viewers may also feel a twinge of unease at how familiar all the brands are to them, reminding them that they too are culprits, and the builders of this labyrinth. As if to make the picture even worse, right at the top of the painting is a cramped array of new cardboard boxes, impatiently wanting to squeeze themselves into the picture. It seems to spell the ominous question - Does the world know when to stop?

Also, this painting is almost devoid of life, except for two boys, lying in a loose fetal position, weak and helpless. The way in which they are arranged - limbs and all - practically scream out their helplessness, faced with the impossible task of getting out of this maze. As the only human figures in the painting, and in their weak state, they naturally evoke a feeling of sympathy in the viewers. In this aspect, the never-ending cardboard boxes seem even more sinister, as they are the cause of the childrens' suffering.

I think that the main point of the painting is how it portrays the relationship between poverty and industrialization. While there have been countless representations and documentaries and what not on poverty, this painting is a still a stand-out among the billions of other representations. This is primarily due to the fact that most of the other representations only show a picture of say a factory spewing smoke next to a village, or children walking barefooted to work in sweatshops etc. Only showing singular cases and examples. However, "Labyrinth" stands out due to its attempt to portray the entire situation of poverty and consumerism in its magnitude in one picture. Just using one picture to show this huge problem clearly reinforces the message and makes sure to deliver it with a huge impact. He also cleverly makes the boxes seem to carry on even off the canvas to show that this is still not the full picture.

Monday, May 16, 2011

AEP Lucia Hartini assignment!

1. (a) Describe the use of space, colour and brushwork.

In this painting, “Srikandi”, Lucia Hartini separates the painting into foreground, middle ground and background. In the foreground, we see a huge woman who bears great likeness to the artist herself, taking up more than half of the canvas, standing in a warrior stance and draped with blue cloth. This central positioning of the woman emphasizes that she is the main subject matter and makes her the first thing viewers will see as they view the painting. In the middle ground, are zigzagging walls that lead into the distance, providing depth to the painting and leading the viewer’s eyes to the background. In it, are turbulent clouds and a bright moon, creating a sort of contradiction as the clouds seem very violent as compared to the calmness the moon provides. This highlights that unsettling tone of the painting as possibly intended by Lucia Hartini. Another use of space in this painting is how Lucia Hartini splits her painting into two parts: the sky and the straight wall, and the eyes and the zigzagged wall, with herself in the middle separating the two. Previously in “Spying Eyes” (1989), we see that both walls are zigzagged and the composition is rather haphazard with the eyes all over the place, the artist shrunk and cuddled up in a fetal position and the sky shrouded with dark turbulent clouds. It is safe to assume that the brick walls are symbolic of the odds in Lucia Hartini’s life and in “Srikandi”, we see that one of the walls (the wall behind her) is straight, as though she has already straightened out half of the odds in her life, and is now facing the rest. This is highlighted by the sky as instead of being shrouded with dark turbulent clouds as in “Spying Eyes”, there is now a bright moon rising out of it, lighting the sky up with hope. Lucia Hartini wished to depict herself as a brave, strong warrior woman which she did so by painting herself facing her adversities (the eyes and the remaining zigzagged wall) with determination.

In “Srikandi”, Lucia Hartini uses earthly tones for the skin of the woman, possibly to contrast the woman as natural as compared to the unnatural setting she is in. She also primarily uses only blues and oranges in the painting – complementary colours. Her use of complementary colours to contrast the earthly toned walls and skin with the rich blue cloth and clouds boldens and brightens the entire painting and makes the warrior woman stand out even more, as well as making the painting one that exudes confidence and has a bold story to tell.

As for brushwork, Lucia Hartini has executed her brushstrokes carefully and smoothly, making them nearly invisible to the human eye. This makes the work extremely realistic, despite its unrealistic composition and subject matter. The seemingly absent brushstrokes also lets the viewers subconsciously forget this aspect of painting and concentrate on the symbolic subject matter and composition instead.

1. (b) Comment on the influences behind this work.

Firstly, the unrealistic composition and subject matter show influences from Surrealism. Surrealism is based on the irrational combination of unrelated objects and contrasting forms derived from the depths of imagination or the dream world, or a fusing of the dream world with reality to bewilder the viewer. Lucia Hartini lived in a culture where a straightforward, critical or confessional discourse is not acceptable and thus turned to Surrealism to encase symbolic messages within.

Secondly, she was possibly most influenced by Srikandi, the archetypical “Warrior Woman” of South East Asian legends for this painting. She depicted herself as Srikandi, dressed in the blue cloth worn by members of the women’s armies who historically protected the Sultans of feudal Java. Lucia Hartini painted herself as Srikandi, repelling the critical and doubting eyes of society which had rendered many of its women prisoners of tradition.

Thirdly, would be the culture are lived in. In the Indonesia that she lived in, the status of a woman always depends on the male and she is always regarded inferior to the man, an object of the man’s orders and admonition. Because of this, Indonesian women and prisoners of tradition, having to inherit society’s expectations of them to play the role of a mother, caring for children and not having the rights to express themselves freely, always fearing society’s critical and doubtful eyes. This could arguably have influenced Lucia Hartini’s obsession with spying eyes, and subsequently, her wish to have the power to stare back at the eyes and defy them, symbolic of her having enough confidence to stand up for her own rights against societal norms.

A valid interpretation of an artwork is dependent on an understanding of the artist’s intent and the context in which it was created.

Interpreting artwork is not only the livelihood of art critiques but also an unavoidable process which happens every time anyone sees an artwork. A person need not be an art critique to interpret a work, thus the nature of interpretations taking on many forms. Although everyone believes that their interpretation is correct, I personally believe that a valid interpretation of an artwork is dependent on an understanding of the artist’s intent and the context in which it was created.

The artist’s intent is, possibly, the most important aspect to take into consideration in order to make a valid interpretation of his or her work. In order to even create a work, an artist will almost always have a purpose in making the work. Be it as a response to an issue or as an avenue of expression, understanding the purpose of the work is possibly the most important step one needs to take in order to make a valid interpretation. An example would be Olympia by Manet. When it was exhibited in the Paris Salon of 1865, it caused an uproar. Critiques all over deemed it as “vulgar” and “immoral”, even going to the extent of saying that if the painting were not destroyed, it is only because it is well-protected. I feel that these interpretations, although made with good basis, were not valid interpretations. Manet meant for this painting to simply show the truth. This work, known to some as Manet’s “masterpiece”, was so violently slammed in its time due to the simple reason of interpreters not understanding the artist’s intent.

Context is also extremely important in interpreting a work, such as in the case of Lucia Hartini. Her painting of “Srikandi”, is full of symbols which any art critique can easily link with courage, barricades, freedom and defiance, but without truly understanding the context in which the painting was painted, the interpretation of “a courageous woman breaking out of barricades and seeking freedom” will never be complete. This painting was painted by Lucia Hartini in her Indonesian society which was extremely male-dominant. Female artists such as her suffer in both art school and society as they are looked upon with a critical eye and their works are not recognized. Her influences for this work were not only the society she lived in, but also of her longing to break free of societal norms and in the process, discover herself. Understanding her context to paint this painting, we can then form a valid interpretation that she is depicting herself as Srikandi, fighting back against the critical judgement and norms of society.

Therefore it can be said that understanding the intent and context of an artist is crucial in forming a valid interpretation of the artwork.